brigid: (9CL)
[personal profile] brigid
Just Stuff:
I forgot Edda isn't Catholic which is odd given her Irish-American forbears. Her Lutheran grandmother would have been expected to convert to Catholicism if they were married in the Church. Gran's a German Catholic, apparently. Edda attends a Catholic school but that doesn't mean anything, it's super common for Catholic schools in the USA to have non-Catholic students, and her friend Mary Rosenzweig is Jewish.
Cardinal Feeny, Sister Steven's brother. Their family must have had a LOT of children if two of them took vows. Anyway, Cardinal Feeny's drawn with the correct garb here. He isn't always.

Set in New Hampshire when not in NY

First mention of "Monty" as God's name.


Sister Aramus aka Diane Fallon aka Diane Durly:


Character Details and Drift, Amos:
Amos' hair used to be less curly/scribbly and more... troll-doll-like? Generally unkempt. I prefer the curly hair. He also used to have a larger nose. Much larger.
Amos had a thing for a girl named Marsha Armand. Edda went on a tear insulting her intelligence in a previous strip.
Stuff used to get tangled in Amos' hair, including "The Big Book of Dutch Humor," which later comes up in the Brussels story line.
Amos' parents are shit.
Amos is twelve here and still believes in Santa Claus.
I'm going to be honest, I don't get the punchline. I feel like it's incredibly obvious and I'm just overlooking it, but maybe not? Like is it implied that different sects of Christianity are different brands and his version of Christianity is generic? Anyway, they could just say "Happy Holidays."
This is a "classics" strip so I'm not sure of the year, but Amos had a crush on Sister Aramus.
Amos used to have a lot of math, physics, science, et interests. He used to be much more multifaceted.
Amos used to be a more general nerd/"genius" interested in physics and atomic theory, not just music and big words
"Taking Over The World" was a recurring theme
He used to be even more off-putting, and was also constantly pursuing Mary
Again, science/math geekery that's been lost over time
Amos used to be kind of an asshole, and also stood up to Edda
He really did call her out on her bullshit several times, including earlier in this story where he dumps her
Sometimes Amos is allowed to find other people attractive.
Sometimes I forget that Amos plays piano. Here's some other stuff (not sex) he's great at.
Amos hates squishy sounds, which includes ear stuff. There's times he's repulsed by it. Also sometimes mouth kissing is too noisy and gross for him and I really have to wonder just how sloppily someone has to kiss for it to be offensively noisy.


Character Details and Drift, Edda:


Character Details and Drift, Seth:


Mark:
Mark was Seth's super gay art gallery owning three piece suit wearing wild haired barbie loving boyfriend.


Fernanda Jons:
Fernanda Jons is an exquisite dancer, is from Argentina, and is a homophobic bigot

Character Development and Drift, Juliette:


Character Development and Drift, Gran:


Character Development and Drift, Mary Rosenzweig:


Edda and Amos Childhood Relationships:
We Must Never Marry
NYE Kiss #1
They alternate between being destined lovers of a great romance and... dating other people.
Edda states they can never have a romantic relationship, Amos believes otherwise.
Mary Rosenzwieg is introduced, Amos' longest-lasting obsession. There was also a girl named Marsha.
Wishing on a star (for Mary). I actually prefer it when an author doesn't set up an end romance between kids. No big destined fate love. Just two people who grow together.
Edda wonders if they'll ever meet other people and fall in love. This is really nice, actually. Good art, good poses, nice backgrounds, nice quip, and it's cool to see them so physically intimate in a way that isn't sexual/sensual. It grounds them as friends. Also I like Amos' hair.
"Falling In Love" means "horny."
Edda "necks" with unnamed boys who aren't Amos
Their designated pairing started earlier than I remember, here with the end of a story involving a flash forward.
20 years ago these two were already discussing procreating... with Amos still attempting to date Mary now and then but not, like, an exciting or dramatic way
More "father of my children" stuff. Edda has always felt more possessive of Amos than he has felt of her, and while willing to claim him has always kept her options open as to hotter dudes.
And again, the joke is that Amos loves Edda, who is hot stuff, but Amos is ehhhhh
But does it matter, when shortly after Amos is back to begging Mary for scraps of love?
Amos continues stalking Mary; a few strips ago Edda was on a date with a good-looking creep. But soulmates, right?

Edda and Amos Adult Relationships:


Gross:


Music to Fuck To:


Table Fucking:


Piano (and other instrument) Fucking:


Boner Comics:


Lingerie Obsession:


Is this... meta-commentary?


The Whole Abortion Thing:


Fetishes, Various Types:


That Mouth Thing (you know, with all the teeth):


Bales of Straw, Everywhere:


Flashback! Edda and Amos as small children who want to have babies:
In late 2022 McEldowney started heavily featuring flashback comic strips to when Edda and Amos were younger, ranging in from from six (or younger?) to early teen years, where they just... talk about having a baby/babies. Sometimes "Yeah, let's have kids when we're older" and other times "Let us now shake hands upon our agreement to conceive and bear X number of children of these genders." And asking Juliette to describe an orgasm. As I was going through the archives I was surprised at how long ago he started doing this.


The Bad Woman:




Regionalism, I guess:


Queering the Strip:
McEldowney is deeply homophobic although I'm sure he thinks of himself as even handed and not a bigot, and he apparently doesn't know that bisexuality/pansexuality/etc exist. He plays with gender in interesting ways sometimes, though. Men wear high heels, or panty hose, or dance with each other, and it doesn't quite feel like THEY are the punchline. The fact that it's unexpected is the punchline. It doesn't feel cruel. This predominantly concerns Amos, but sometimes Thorax. I might go through and do a post about this, specifically.


What?:


It's a fantasy, after all:


Story Beats:


Some of my favorites:
What a dump!
Or was that Dracula?
Chessmate/In Captivity
It's rare we see Gran - ESPECIALLY Old Gran - standing up for Juliette.
This reminds me of when men compliment women and women respond with "thanks" or "I know."
"have you been eating tuna?"
Short One Vertebra I have a soft spot for Elliot.
My Mind Was Elsewhere
Sketchy Memory
I really like it when he plays with borders and gutters
I mean, cats.
I don't have any strong feelings about this strip in general, but McEldowney is really underrated when it comes to body horror, this is fantastic
It's disappointing that we don't get this aspect of Amos' personality/character any more, the set up and punch line are great
"This isn't one of those areas where I welcome discussion" is a great line, sorry not sorry
Spot Blacks and Whites
Not at all funny, or subtle, but absolutely taking a stand against Greyhound racing (although it's odd to only target Florida?. 18 years later and there's only 3 Greyhound racing tracks in all of the USA.
I remain a sucker for the spot blacks, and for the grace of their arms and hands.
Amos' face and pose is very dynamic in the first panel and the snow storm is very well portrayed.
I love that Isabel is using two chairs.
"Clearly you've lost your mind."
This feels so incredibly neurodivergent and I don't know if this is pulling from personal behavior or "this is what weirdos do" but either way I identify with it.
So much of this story (Edda thinks she's pregnant, forgets what pregnancy tests are) is awful but some of it is fantastic. I really like this one.
On the one hand this is yet another comic strip about their sex lives. On the other hand it's really funny.
"What I really want" (from a WWII flashback story)
When I was this age I hesitated to rent R-Rated movies for fear my parents would disapprove. I get it.
String instruments are predators draining the life blood of musicians is something I can get behind.
Tying your shoes to hide from Isabel is hilarious, actually.
Hard Boiled Private Dick Elliot Green is adorable. So is his brief foray into writing comic strips.
I'm sad. And I fell asleep.
1) it's nice to hear Amos bragged about 2) I love the surreality of this. Just walking up to a random (?) person, saying this, and then walking away.
I also like your... um... blouse.

Profile

9chickweedlane: (Default)
9 Chickweed Lane

November 2024

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10 11 1213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 28th, 2025 02:05 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios